Dating a Cancer Man in 2023: Pros, Cons, Things to Know

Interested in dating a Cancer man? Astrology is a great way to understand someone and their personality, as well as predict the potential trouble a relationship must face. For decades, people have relied on the stars to help them find their destiny, and it can even help you make it work with someone you believe to be your true love!

If you’re dating a Cancer man or just hoping to, this guide will give you all of the juicy insider information that you need to know in order to make the relationship healthy, strong, and long-lasting.

Find That Cancer Man in Your Life…

If you need help hookup up or dating a cancer man, use these recommended sites:

5 Star Dating Review #1 Hookup website! Large member base. Free to try.

Try Now

eharmony is a great dating site 5 Star Dating Review #1 Dating Site. Largest active member based of Zodiac-interested singles. Free to try!

Try Now

What A Cancer Is Really Like

dating a cancer man

Cancer is ruled by the moon, so picture a Cancer man as a physical manifestation of the moon itself. A little mysterious, a little far-away and dreamy, but a very compassionate and emotional presence that is important on the Earth. In a nutshell, that is a Cancer man.

Looking a little closer, you’ll start to see that like the moon rules the tide, emotions rule the Cancer. They lack confidence but make up for that in loads of compassion and they make excellent family men. Nothing else can measure up to their ability to love, care, and take care of others. The downside to this can be the insecurities that come from such a selfless nature. Reassurance and validation are important for a Cancer.

Starting to sound a little familiar? Many Cancer man fall into these classic traits, and Cancer is symbolized as a crab. This relates to their water element and also to the way they handle life. Inside they’re soft and sweet, but the fear of the unknown and potential failure give them a hard shell that takes time to break through.

Pros of Dating a Cancer Man

Most Cancer signs are known for their romantic, caring, and homely nature. For relationships, this is an excellent personality to have, so if you have a Cancer man in your grasp, feel grateful! These man make wonderful, wholesome lovers and lifelong partners. Breaking through their classic “shell” will get you closer to all these amazing parts of a Cancer man in a relationship.

Great listeners

Since Cancer men aren’t big on starting a conversation, they rely more on listening and remembering. Tell a Cancer man something once and he’ll remember it forever! They enjoy hearing about others, their interests, and stories. When they feel comfortable, they’ll start contributing to the conversation too, but until then, you won’t ever fear being interrupted or ignored. Cancer’s listen and they retain what you say because it genuinely matters to them.

Goes with the flow

While a Cancer is uncomfortable being the one to make a plan, they’re mostly fine with anything. Cancer man are just very flexible and easy to please, and they don’t mind doing much. Though they prefer to stay close to home, a Cancer man will tag along with their partner if asked, and they enjoy handing the reins over to someone else. It’s really not a big deal to them if things change or plans fall through.

Cares deeply

The emotional capacity of a Cancer man is incredible! Empathy and compassion are the two biggest things that remain true in any Cancer sign. From small to large things, your Cancer partner will care, and they’ll never stop showing it either. A Cancer also won’t be afraid to show that emotion, so it’s not uncommon to have a heart-to-heart or see some tears.

Cons of Dating a Cancer Man

If it all seems too good to be true, that’s because it is. Cancer man have great qualities, but it’s at a high cost. Some of the best things about your Cancer man could be his biggest shortcomings, too. Realizing ahead of time where problems may lie within his nature will help you prevent the issues before they begin, or give you insight how to resolve them.

Overly emotional


Yes, Cancer man care deeply, but sometimes… it’s too much. Their feelings are always first and foremost and it’s easy to hurt them even with a simple joke. They take things to heart, and can sometimes act a bit like a victim over little things. Everything is a big deal to a Cancer man, so you’ll need to handle these emotional breaks pretty often, and be careful of trodding on their sensitivity.

A little manipulative

“Needy” is sometimes a word that is associated with Cancer. It’s not really their fault, it’s just because they are a person who feels things so deeply, their wants and desires become so important to them. Sometimes, it’s so important they’ll do whatever it takes to get what they want… and that includes some manipulation tactics.

Possessive nature

No one taught a Cancer man how to share as a child. They are proud of their belongings, both physical and metaphysical. What is theirs they truly believe is theirs fair and square, so they’ll be quick to jump to the defense if they feel threatened. Remember how their symbol is a crab in the zodiac? Think pinchers! Because of this, a Cancer man can have a nasty jealous streak.

Crab in the zodiac? Think pinchers! Because of this, a Cancer man can have a nasty jealous streak.

5 Secret Tips To Win Them Over

Don’t give up or feel discouraged by the hard outer shell of a Cancer. They may seem distant and far away in the beginning, but it’s really quite easy to sneak through the barrier and get to his heart. Cancer men crave love and affection, but their fear of failure holds them back from pursuing it. Following these 5 easy tricks will get you inside that wall and nestled tightly in his affectionate hold.

1. Make the first move

talking woman

Expecting initiation or bravery from a Cancer man is a direct route to failure. If you’re waiting for him to make a move, you’ll be dead ‘n gone before that happens. Cancer men don’t like to act without reassurance that they won’t face failure. Think of it as them putting their toe in the water first, checking the temperatures… The Cancer man needs to feel safe.

Since you probably feel like the sooner the best, feel free to express your interest first, even as a woman. These men don’t mind their lady taking the lead in this sense, and it will encourage them to open up a little more and allow them to be comfortable enough to truly make the move that they need to make. Give the Cancer man you like your number, or ask to get him a drink. Before long, he’ll be comfortable enough to ask you out next time, once that little push out of the nest is past.

2. Show interest in his family

Family is everything to a Cancer man. Your Cancer interest is most definitely a Momma’s Boy, so ask him about his mom. He’ll want you to meet them, and he values his family opinion highly. Pass the test with them and you’re in for life. The nurturing and domestic personality of a Cancer sign leads to this strong familial bond, and it’ll come in handy later on when you’re ready to start your own. They make excellent dads, brothers, husbands, and sons because family trumps all else in their world.

On the flip side of that concept, don’t be afraid to show him your own home life, too. A partner who values family as much as him will be even more appealing in a Cancer man’s eyes, so talk about your mom and dad and sibling. Share holidays or family events with your Cancer partner and show him how domestic you can be, too. Cook and clean, as traditional and old-fashioned as it sounds, for him and he’ll be hooked, too.

3. Allow yourself to be vulnerable

Despite having a hard time making the first move, a Cancer man really does want to feel needed by his partner. Maybe this stems from his own insecurities over his own needy nature, but he has a deep desire to nurture and care for you. If a Cancer man feels useless or like he doesn’t contribute enough, he’ll grow unhappy and that gloomy presence could derail an otherwise perfect union.

It’s always hard to let someone in enough so that they can see your vulnerabilities, and it’s even harder to allow them to solve those problems for you. You can start small, but it’s vital to the success of your relationship that you do share your own insecure side with him at some point and let him “fix” your problems.

4. Be affectionate

cancer man dating in 2019

Physical connection for a Cancer man is just as important as that emotional bond they value so strongly. A lot of Cancer men are known as clingy lovers, enjoying all sorts of sweet gestures and forehead kisses, hand-holding, and snuggles. They enjoy being showered in praise and affirming statements, and always told how loved they are.

Affection should be the main focus point of your relationship with a Cancer man, both by touch and verbal reassurance. If you feel a disconnect between the two of you, offer him a shoulder message or kiss his hand while you hold it. Every little thing that is done in a relationship to a Cancer man is remembered and appreciated. The very best part about this trait is that a Cancer man will give you it all back tenfold. Seriously, he will never let you go if you let him cling forever.

5. Never judge his insecurities

Think back to that overly emotional tidbit about a Cancer man. Remember how he takes things personally, how easily his emotions can be hurt? The feelings of a Cancer man will often be even more important than you in a relationship, so take his heart carefully and try to avoid casting judgement on his sensitive side.

Cancer men aren’t exactly fragile since they’re experts at protecting themselves from the cruel world, but once they let someone in, that is a major enough commitment that it’ll crush him if you judge his insecurities or fears. Instead, use positive words, and try to keep things neutral and blameless when arguing. Don’t give a Cancer man reason to shut down and put a wall between you back up, because it’s harder breaking through a second or third time.

Compatible Signs for Dating a Cancer Man

Feeling pretty good yet about dating a Cancer man? Or maybe a few things have given you reason to pause and really consider if pursuing your Cancer sign love interest is worth the challenge. Either way, all could be revealed by analyzing your own sign compared to his!

Best Matches

The stars dictate the best matches for a Cancer man, so cross your fingers and check and see if your sign follows:

  • Taurus. Humble Taurus lovers are the best match for the sensitive Cancer. They care almost as much and almost as deeply, and understand how debilitating insecurities can be. The two are also both pretty food-obsessed, so that’s a great shared interest!
  • Pisces. Water signs have excellent compatibility with each other. Pisces and Cancer are truly twin flames, two sides of the same soul, and both so deeply rooted in their emotions that together, they make up an entire lifetime of feelings. See this article on Pisces man for more info.
  • Virgo. The organized, take-charge nature of a Virgo is ideal for an unmotivated Cancer who always needs little extra push. Though as an Earth sign, Virgo people are very intact with their emotions and have a deep understanding of the importance of feelings. See this article on Virgo woman for more info.

Didn’t see your sign? You may not be naturally compatible with a Cancer man, and the galaxy could be predicting rough waters ahead. Some signs just have a harder time breaking through the Cancer man’s crab shell and getting to the heart, or if they do, they’re careless when handling his delicate soul.

Challenging Matches

The signs that face the most challenges dating a Cancer man are:

  • Gemini. Everything about a Gemini is a polar opposite to the Cancer man. Where they are confident and outgoing, a Cancer sign is quiet and laid back. Adventure rules Gemini but family and home attract a Cancer. These couples have a wild ride ahead. See this article on Gemini man for more info.
  • Aries. Hot-headed Aries are prone to mistakenly hurting feelings with their brazen nature and quick tongue. They like to act first, think later, and don’t really put much stock into sparing emotions, which can be detrimental to a Cancer man’s stability.
  • Libra. In general, air signs and water signs don’t mix. Gemini and Libra are both air signs, like Aquarius, so all three share big conflicts when it comes to personality and mental stability. Libra doesn’t like to deal much with emotional labor, and a Cancer lives for it.

Ready To Date A Cancer?

By now, you can tackle any challenge a Cancer man lover throws at you! You should understand the ways they are delicate and fragile but also see how valuable their heart and compassion is. If you’re with a Cancer man, hold him close, because they’re all sweet souls.

Here are our recommended dating and hookup sites:

5 Star Dating Review #1 Hookup website! Large member base. Free to try.

Try Now

eharmony is a great dating site 5 Star Dating Review #1 Dating Site. Largest active member based of Zodiac-interested singles. Free to try!

Try Now

chelsea king - chief editor of romancescams
Written by Chelsea King

Chelsea has been a direct victim of romance scams herself losing over $35,000 in a span of a year in 2015. She joined and took over operations of in 2015. She brings first-hand experience in studying romance scams, and also experience in vetting dating sites for legitimacy. Read more of Chelsea's articles.

Other Related Articles