Christian Mingle vs eHarmony: 2023 Dating Site Comparison

Everyone, since the beginning of time, has been searching for the key to finding true love. We’ve heard about it in fairytales and watched it in romance movies. Some have found it, others are still on the hunt for the perfect someone.

With more online dating websites in existence today than ever before, it can still be extremely frustrating to determine which website is going to meet all of your specifics, especially when you’re left with questions unanswered.

This review is going to attempt to answer as many of those questions as possible with a comparison of two of the most reputable dating websites to date, Christian Mingle vs eHarmony.

Christian Mingle vs eHarmony: Overall Review

While most dating websites were created around the general concept of bringing people together, Christian Mingle is a dating service that was created specifically for Christian singles who are looking for others with a life focused around their faith in God. Since its initial launch in 2001, the website has gained a following of over 16 million members worldwide, and continues to receive over 1 million visits monthly.

eHarmony, on the other hand, was established with a more open target audience of essentially anyone who is single and looking for a long-term relationship, yet introducing more tailored matches to you based on your specific personality survey. eHarmony has gained an astounding 66 million members since its launch in 2000, and receives over 5 million visits every month.

Christian Mingle Rating: 6/10

If you’re in need of somewhere to begin seeking someone who is assured to match your beliefs, fundaments, and your overall outlook on life, Christian Mingle is certainly a great place to start. Not only have they gained popularity among Christian singles due to the community among the website, but also from the ability to receive similar characteristics that most major dating websites have to offer.

Unfortunately, this service is seemingly exclusive to only the religious population, which makes Christian Mingle a poor option for anyone outside of the religious realm.

eHarmony Rating: 8/10

eHarmony has established a dating website that offers a variety of ways to find love for the variety of members that it contains. A majority of eHarmony’s community has the simple mission of finding someone to settle down with, rather than simple dates or hookups, which can’t be said for many other dating sites.

You’re likely to seek out someone who matches a majority of your criteria that you enter through eHarmony’s extensive matchmaking questionnaire, no matter who you are, your beliefs, nor your sexuality, as there is something to be had for everyone. Their services come at a relatively high price in comparison to most dating websites, but their success rate is nearly uncomparable, so nearly every penny is well spent within the membership.

Winner: eHarmony

Of course, when it comes to simplicity, eHarmony tends to take a different approach. As one once said, “good things come to those who wait.” By asking for a little more effort and patience from you with the extensive questions and get-to-know-yous, they can accomplish a successful, more personal and accurate result on your behalf, rather than only asking a few questions and receiving possibly more generic results.

They seem to offer an overall more inclusive approach to online dating in comparison to Christian Mingle, which is why eHarmony is the clear winner in this category.

Christian Mingle vs eHarmony: Pricing

Christian Mingle Pricing: 7/10

Christian mingle pricing review

Christian Mingle offers two forms of membership plans: the Standard Plan, and the Premium Plan. Both plans come in the form of 1, 3, and 6 month increments, but the long term plans seem to save you more money in the long run, and they do bill you for the entirety of your  membership length up front.

With the Standard Plan, you can send and receive messages to anyone you are matched with, hide your profile if you choose to, and browse anonymously as well.

With the Premium Plan, your spectrum of communication broadens limitlessly, and gives you the ability to further control your privacy. It is absolutely free to view who you are matched with through Christian Mingle, but any form of contact beyond that does require a membership.

Standard Plan

  • 1 Month- 29.99 $ / Month
  • 3 Months- 19.99 $ / Month
  • 6 Months- 14.99 $ / Month

Premium Plan

  • 1 Month- 49.99 $ / Month       
  • 3 Months- 34.99 $ / Month     
  • 6 Months- 24.99 $ / Month     

eHarmony Pricing: 9/10

eHarmony pricing review

With eHarmony, they allow you to “try before you buy” a good majority of their services for free before you commit to their membership plans, which is, again, more inclusive for those who are truly hesitant about spending money on a dating service altogether.

They offer their Basic membership in 1, 6, 12, and 24 month increments, and the Total Connect membership is offered in 3, 6, and 12 month increments, saving you more money the longer the membership term that you purchase, as seen below in the general overview of their pricing options.

The PREMIER membership is offered in only 12 month increments, but with the ability to pause your account for up to 3 months. At no cost to you, you can contact your matches via email.

Basic Plan

  • 1 Month – 59.95$ / Month
  • 6 Months – 39.95$ / Month
  • 12 Months – 18.95$ / Month
  • 24 Months – 9.95$ / Month

Total Connect Plan

  • 3 Months – 44.95$ / Month
  • 6 Months – 33.95$ / Month
  • 12 Months – 23.95$ / Month

Winner: eHarmony

While it may seem like the price does not come with any value if you can simply email each other your phone numbers and avoid the expense of the membership to use the phone service that they provide, safety and security is extremely important, especially with the endless capabilities and information that the internet holds today.

eHarmony does not have much for competition when it comes to a sense of safety and security when it comes to phone communication, which makes this a very unique feature in their membership in comparison to Christian Mingle, along with many other dating websites.

Christian Mingle vs eHarmony: Demographics

One of the aspects people concern themselves with the most about the online dating community is whether or not certain communities contain someone that matches the preferences they specifically have that attracts them to someone in the first place, whether that be age, sexual orientation, ethnicity, or their religious background.

Christian Mingle Members: 3/10

Christian Mingle Members review

With over 1 million visits per month to their website, one would assume that Christian Mingle would hold quite a diverse community. Christian Mingles’ male-to-female ratio proves fairly equal, with 44% being men and 56% being women.

Their ethnicity percentile, on the other hand, shows that 76% of all of their members are primarily Caucasian, while Asian, African American, Hispanic/Latino, and all other ethnicities make up a meer 24% combined.

In the age category, a majority of Christian Mingles’ community shares a 3 primarily equal categories:

  • 25 – 34 being 24%,
  • 35 – 44 being 25%,
  • 45 – 54 being 23%
  • 18 – 24 being 15%.

eHarmony Members: 4/10

eHarmony Members review

eHarmony receives over 5 million visits to their website in a single month worldwide, which creates an exceptionally large chance to obtain an array of members from all different backgrounds that match an array of preferences, but eHarmony holds a similar demographic in nearly every category in comparison to Christian Mingle.

Their male-to-female ratio is nearly equal with a slightly higher population in women (54%) than men (46%). When it comes to ethnicity, eHarmony’s members are:

  •  Caucasian at 68%,
  • Asian at 17%
  • African American & Hispanic/Latino at 15%.

In addition, eHarmony’s membership base is primarily between the ages of 18 and 24 (30%), while the ages of 25 – 34, 35 – 44, and 45 – 54 together make up 20%, and the lowest percentile being above the age of 55 (11%).

Winner: eHarmony

While neither websites provided exceptional demographic content, eHarmony holds slightly more diversity in ethnicity than Christian Mingle, which is why eHarmony is recommended in this category. eHarmony has a slightly tighter age group in comparison to Christian Mingle, but overall has more equal demographics and a better chance for preference satisfaction for its members.  

Christian Mingle vs eHarmony: Who is better at being Scam-Free?.

Christian Mingle vs eHarmony: Who is better at being Scam-Free

As with most things in life, there are always well-hidden dangers in the online dating world, and many people use the tools provided through dating services to fulfill much different intentions. Countless people have been tangled up in a counterfeit form of love, and it is important to know what red flags to be alert for when communicating with someone new that you may be interested in.

Fortunately, with online dating websites that require a paid membership, you are much less likely to come across a scammer, which can be said about both Christian Mingle and eHarmony. Both websites are very reliable when it comes to safe online dating experiences, so there’s no real clear winner in this category.

Christian Mingle vs eHarmony: Features Comparison

Every dating website is different in what they offer to their paying customers, so we will take a more in-depth look at what each of the two websites have to offer below.

Christian Mingle Features: 6/10

Christian Mingle Features review

As mentioned earlier, Christian Mingle doesn’t have a whole lot of unique properties to differentiate itself from other dating sites beyond their efficient matchmaking system, but some may appreciate this. While avoiding adding the extra features and attention to their website, they’re composing themselves in a much more professional way by appearing as a more serious and old-fashioned company that is solely focused on matching Christian singles with their soulmates.

  • Create your custom matchmaking profile through their efficient questionnaire
  • Sending and receiving messages from other paid users
  • Hiding your profile from match potentials if you’re looking for more security through their website
  • Receiving a notification when your messages are seen by the recipient
  • Hiding your online status
  • You can browse other profiles anonymously

eHarmony Features: 6/10

eHarmony Features review

eHarmony offers a good majority of their features free for non-member users, which makes it an immersive website to investigate when shopping around for dating websites to test out without spending a ton of money.

If you decide to begin with the Basic Membership, this will unlock a few more features for you to be able to play with:

  • Ability to view photos that are posted to the personal profile of whomever you are matched with, as well as request personal photos from your matches
  • You will be able to spark new conversations as well as receive communication requests limitlessly with your matches
  • Ability to see everyone who has searched through your profile that was matched with you, and
  • Given access to timestamps of when your matches were last logged into their account

With the Total Connect Membership, you’re granted access to a few more features than the Basic Membership. These features include:

  • A much more in-depth personality profile that allows you to be more custom with your preferences, as well as the ability to make a larger first impression with all of the added information you give your match
  • RelyID, a tool used to verify member identification, is included in the Total Connect Membership and allows you to further protect yourself from online scammers by showing you matches that also have RelyID, and
  • SecureCall, a service that allows members to securely communicate over the phone or arrange in-person events without revealing any personal information to whomever they are communicating with, is also included in this membership

Winner: Christian Mingle

Christian Mingle owns a very clear and concise set of features that, although not very unique, make it extremely easy to navigate their membership inclusions and their site overall. Although eHarmony clearly has many more features, as well as unique ones, it could be overwhelming for a good majority of people to understand what features come free to them and what features require a membership to utilize them, as it was hard information to find just for this category.

Christian Mingle vs eHarmony: Dating Success

Christian Mingle vs eHarmony: Dating Success

If you are looking for a website with a clear focus on the type of people they are trying to match, Christian Mingle is definitely the one. Although they don’t leave much room for people who live outside of the religious community, they are still a tremendously successful website that has brought thousands of Christian couples together. If you are a Christian single looking to make a lifetime connection with someone who shares your faith and has a personal relationship with God, Christian Mingle has intentions with your mission in mind and would be a no-doubt perfect online dating website for you.

On the other hand, if you’re on the prowl for a dating site that really provides you with a variety of tools to customize your own dating experience and tailor it to your own preferences, eHarmony will be the online dating pool you’ll want to dive into. Their personality profile matchmaking system is very particular and, yes, time consuming, but this advanced system is what has connected millions of compatible couples over the last 19 years and counting.

Both websites are perfect for putting you where you would like to be in your love life, so deciding which of these sites to use is ultimately up to your personal preference of either quick and efficient or extensive and thorough, cost effective or top dollar, and your overall ability to be specific or general when filling out your interest profile.

Verdict: Which is Best?

In the end, when deciding between Christian Mingle vs EHarmony, eHarmony seems to be the superior option between the two, as the website has far more to offer its members who are looking for something more personalized and effective. Their extensive matchmaking process makes for a well deserved result of much more compatible matches, and are inclusive of Christian singles as well as all other types of single people in the world. eHarmony has everything that Christian Mingle has to offer, along with much, much more.

While the prices are a little steep, they are absolutely worth it for the added safety features and multiple ways to communicate with one another. All in all, they know exactly what you’re looking for, and they have obtained all of the ways to help you find your perfect soulmate. All it takes is you.

chelsea king - chief editor of romancescams
Written by Chelsea King

Chelsea has been a direct victim of romance scams herself losing over $35,000 in a span of a year in 2015. She joined and took over operations of in 2015. She brings first-hand experience in studying romance scams, and also experience in vetting dating sites for legitimacy. Read more of Chelsea's articles.

Other Related Articles